Catalina Crunch Protein Cookies, 4g Protein per Serving | Low-Sugar Sandwich Cookies | Gluten Free, Vegan | Keto Dessert Snacks - Chocolate Mint, 5.9 oz. (14 Count)

The formula/recipe is different since the last time I had these. Previously the outer cookies were super dense and hard to bite, the chocolate was not dark and didn't actually have the black cocoa taste unique to Oreos (and off brand Oreos) but still so good for the mint. Didn't care for the vanilla or chocolate with vanilla centers, the taste was way off, but the mint ones had enough flavor to make them really good. Taste alone is improved and gets a 5 but ELEVEN net carbs, this is NOT LOW CARB anymore. If it had 3-5 net carbs in 2 cookies, I'd give it a 5 all around. But since it's so high in carbs it's just not worth it. Several of mine were broken and if the carbs had not increased by 40%, I wouldn't even care because they are that good. They actually taste like an Oreo with that black cocoa and the mint is great. But since it's supposed to be keto friendly and it's not and the false advertising says 5 net carbs but the product packaging clearly shows SEVEN, 3 stars is all you get from me.

I was happily surprised by the mint chocolate cookies. It’s very close in texture and taste to Oreos. I don't like Catalina cereal and this isn’t that. ~53 and a born diabetic.

These are so good. I had to put them up so I didn't eat more then the serving. I wish there was more in the package but I will buy them again. Can't wait to try the other flavors

Ordered these cookies to give them a try and loved them! Only complaint is that some of the cookies were crushed but that doesn’t change the fact that they were so good. They were rich, full of flavor, fresh and satisfying. Texture was crunchy and they’re Keto friendly with no artificial flavors or sweeteners. These didn’t disappoint.

These are good cookies, but you don’t get a lot for your money and they put that MALITOL in them I don’t like that, but I order them here and there cause they’re good. I could eat the whole bag. It’s not a big bag.