Peanut Butter & Co. Peanut Butter Variety Pack, 4 Flavors, 16 oz (4 Pack)

The greatest tasting peanut butter ever!!

This is wonderful flavored peanut butter!! A great starter variety. White chocolate wonderful...this is a good, sweet peanut butter. I do not care for white chocolate, but like this pb. My 14yr old states that it tastes much like peanut butter butter cream frosting before thinning(pb, butter, pwd sugar...thinned with milk or heavy cream)...yeah, kinda, maybe a bit less sweet. Dark choc dream...this pb has a taste similar to nutella, a tad more "bitter choc" taste(in a good way-if you are a dark choc fan, you know what I mean) and obviously its a different nut, but same general flavor and mouth feel. Smooth operator...this is super flavorful, great pb! It is like homemade peanut butter that I used to make before I had 3young children(3, 2, 1...its a wonder I have time to write this review ;-)) If you have never had homemade pb and are used to store bought, the difference is amazing!!! Crunch time...this is like homemade pb I used to make with nut pieces thrown in. I cant wait to make cookies with this pb!!! If you have only had mainstream grocery store brands, you are in for a real treat!! If you have had homemade pb, you know what im talking about. I am so happy that I can have homemade peanut butter taste without all the work(pb is easy, the cleanup & storage isnt always...especially with little ones running through the house).

I ordered these on a lark and didn't expect to enjoy them as much as I did. But, each jar is 16oz (1lb) of delicious peanut butter goodness. SMOOTH OPERATOR: This was silky smooth peanut butter (the kind that sticks to the roof of your mouth in large gobs), a touch sweet, and has a lovely fresh roasted peanut taste. CRUNCH TIME: I'll admit I'm not a fan of chunky peanut butter, but this might have converted me. While other chunky peanut butters only include enough peanut chunks to be annoying, this is like eating a handful of fresh roasted peanuts in every bite. Also, it was exceptional for use in peanut butter cookies. WHITE CHOCOLATE WONDERFUL: This was probably my least favourite of the bunch, but still quite yummy. The flavour didn't strike me as white chocolate and the vanilla might have been to blame for that. DARK CHOCOLATE DREAMS: This was my favourite of the bunch. It had a rich chocolate taste, was decadent in its sweetness, with a peanut aftertaste, and it was great on just about everything from bread to bananas. The one thing I'll note about all of these peanut butters is that they're sweet (a couple sweeter than others), though not as bad as some other well-known brands. For me, it's just the right balance of sweet to satisfy my sweet tooth. In fact, I've already branched out to try some of their other peanut butter blends.

For a first time try this was really good peanut butter. I got it to make some Thia food, and really was just going to order the Smooth Operator, but then was like, I really want to try it all. I gave it a 4 because the "White Chocolate" was more like a marshmallow flavor vs. the idea of white chocolate. Not a biggie. My Husband still ate it and it was not wasted by any means! It is a good product. Tasty. A little over priced for the size of the jars.

Tasty, quality ingredients. Although I could have done without the white chocolate.

These taste good, but I should have looked at the label before buying. The regular/smooth flavor has the same sugar as big-brand PBs (like Jif), but PB&Co adds palm oil. The dark chocolate flavor tastes more like Nutella than PB with dark chocolate. I have been looking for a less-expensive alternative to Fix & Fogg dark chocolate PB, but this isn't it! I got the 4-flavor variety pack and they all taste OK - not awful or anything - but just not great. For regular peanut butter (smooth/chunky without added flavors), I'd rather have any of the big-brand items (Peter Pan, Jif, Skippy, etc) or Justins or Smuckers. For the flavored items (dark and white chocolate), there's too much added sugar and they just don't taste that good.

I was leery of buying this product with reading the reviews. I’m glad I did. This peanut butter is delicious. I seen people having issues with it being runny. Mine were the opposite. They were the consistency of a soft fudge. It was hard to spread on toast. But so worth it. I will definitely buy again.

I ordered the pack of four in Spring of 2020 and finished them quickly. The flavor a texture is the BEST I have ever had and I am picky -- paying higher price for organic smooth peanut butters at local healthy markets. WARNING... you may find yourself thinking about this peanut butter at odd times of day, and it could cause addiction in some customers. The negative reviews, I would put into three categories: the competition (yes... they pay people to do negative reviews); the purists (you know... they prefer local small farmers); and the got a bad batchers.